7 Best Pool Automation Systems: Pros and Cons

A brand-new swimming pools is great until you understand the maintenance. Now, owners spend countless hours skimming, checking chemicals, adjusting temperatures, and managing equipment. The best pool automation systems transform the pool care tasks.

Pool automation systems control almost every aspect of your pool from anywhere. Furthermore, quality pool automation controllers manage everything from lights, temperature, water flow, and chemical levels. Therefore, your specific needs determine the best system. Trusted brands like Pentair, Hayward, and Poolside Tech offer reliable options.

Presently, these systems prove their worth beyond just saving time. They substantially cut your monthly energy costs. Basically, automation optimizes pump operations and heater. Additionally, smart features like automated chemical dosing keep water quality perfect. Further, safety features protect your pool and prevent unauthorized access.

The cost varies from a few hundred to several thousand dollars based on your chosen features. Moreover, smart systems can store custom programs for events. Afterwards, you can control lights and water features with one touch.

Pool owners with large installations face unique automation challenges. The Attendant by Poolside Tech addresses these challenges through its extensive control capabilities and cloud-based intelligence.

The Attendant key features

The Attendant serves as a detailed pool command center with these specifications:

• Maximum device management supports up to 50 variable speed pumps and serial connected devices at once
• Visual configuration tool automatically identifies unsafe scenarios to prevent equipment damage
• Universal compatibility works with equipment from major manufacturers including Pentair, Hayward, and Jandy
• Expandable architecture supports up to 8 relay devices, 5 temperature sensors, 5 flow switches, 5 actuators, and 5 low voltage relays
• NSF 50-listed certification as a Water Quality Monitoring Controller ensures stringent safety standards
• Weather-responsive automation exploits forecasts and historical performance data to optimize heating cycles
• Integrated water level management alerts users about potential leaks and offers automatic filling capabilities

The system's integrated chemistry module measures, records, and responds to ongoing chemical needs automatically. This minimizes the need for manual water testing.

The Attendant pros and cons

Pros:

• Vendor-agnostic design works with almost any existing pool equipment
• Patented energy optimization monitors and adjusts for peak efficiency
• System alerts users about dirty filters, obstruction, pump failures, and other problems
• Built-in Airbnb mode limits guest access to specific features and settings
• Spotify integration creates synchronized lighting and music experiences
• Easy-to-use touchscreen interface for local control with a detailed mobile app

Cons:

• Only professional installation available—no self-installation option
• Higher upfront cost than simpler automation systems
• Time needed to master advanced features
• System depends on stable internet connection

The Attendant pricing

The Attendant offers several configurations:

• Simple configurations start at $212 for individual components
• Complete ATT-2 system (with 2 high-voltage relays): $1,500-$2,000
• ATT-8 system (with 8 relays): $2,200-$3,000
• Additional modules like Chemistry Management: $500-$800

Professional installation costs add $500-$1,000 to the total price, depending on system complexity.

The Attendant best for

The Attendant works best for:

• Complex pool systems with multiple pumps, features, and water bodies
• Technical homeowners who want analytical operational insights
• Vacation rental properties that need guest access controls
• Energy-conscious owners looking to reduce operational costs
• Pools with extensive water features needing synchronized control

Smaller automation systems can't match The Attendant's ability to manage 50 devices simultaneously. This makes it the ideal choice for ambitious pool installations with multiple systems.

The Pentair IntelliCenter leads the way in pool automation technology to reduce power bills. This advanced system optimizes pool operations by scheduling equipment use during off-peak electricity hours.

Pentair IntelliCenter key features

The IntelliCenter Control System reshapes pool management with these notable features:

• Control capacity : Manages up to 40 auxiliary circuits for high-powered equipment including pool pumps, lights, and sanitization equipment
• Feature circuits : Contains 32 additional feature circuits that control pump speeds or valve actuators without using auxiliary circuits
• Touchscreen interface : High-resolution, full-color display shows step-by-step setup screens for easy navigation
• Remote access : Built-in connectivity lets you control your pool through the Pentair Pool app on iOS and Android devices from anywhere
• Real-time alerts : Sends instant notifications about potential issues before they affect your pool's performance
• Energy optimization : Reduces electricity costs by scheduling operations during off-peak hours
• Performance monitoring : Tracks equipment efficiency to help reduce operating costs
• Cloud infrastructure : Delivers improved stability, connectivity, and scheduling features with over-the-air updates

The IntelliCenter naturally blends with other Pentair products like the IntelliChlor Salt Chlorine Generator and IntelliFlo VSF pumps to create a detailed automation ecosystem.

Pentair IntelliCenter pros and cons

Pros:

• Smart scheduling and equipment optimization deliver excellent energy savings
• The accessible touchscreen simplifies programming and operation
• The highly-rated Pentair Pool app enables remote monitoring
• Up-to-the-minute alerts prevent equipment damage and lower maintenance costs
• System grows with additional equipment as needed
• USB port saves system configuration files
• System receives automatic firmware updates
• 100 available schedules offer extensive programming options

Cons:

• Bright sunlight makes the touchscreen hard to read
• Some users report temperature sensor calibration issues
• The web client interface needs usability improvements
• Web client has local access limitations
• Advanced function documentation needs more detail
• Google Home and Amazon Alexa support still under development

Pentair IntelliCenter pricing

Pentair IntelliCenter offers different configurations for various pool setups:

• IntelliCenter Load Center : Basic control hub costs around $1,500
• IntelliCenter i8PS Pool and Spa Bundle : Complete package includes touchscreen, valve actuators, relays, temperature sensors and WiFi link kit
• IntelliCenter i5P Personality Kit : A cost-effective choice for mid-range pools
• IntelliCenter Upgrade Kits : Updates older Pentair systems like EasyTouch or IntelliTouch, starting at $580

Expert installation adds $500-1,000 to the total cost based on complexity. Complete installed systems typically cost between $2,000-$3,500.

Pentair IntelliCenter best for

The Pentair IntelliCenter works best for:

• Energy-conscious pool owners who want to minimize electricity costs
• Tech-savvy users who value remote monitoring and control
• Larger pools needing sophisticated automation for multiple features
• Existing Pentair equipment owners wanting natural integration
• Pool service professionals who make use of remote monitoring for proactive maintenance

Pool owners benefit from optimized pump operation times, heater usage, and equipment cycling based on actual usage patterns. The IntelliCenter's energy savings often make up for its initial cost over time.

Pool professionals can use the Pentair Pro desktop app to monitor pools remotely and fix issues with fewer visits. This creates better outcomes for everyone - owners spend less on maintenance while reducing energy use.

The Pentair EasyTouch system makes pool technology simple and takes away the guesswork. This easy-to-use pool automation controller offers a simple approach to pool management without cutting corners on important features.

Pentair EasyTouch key features

The EasyTouch system makes your daily pool operations easy with these features:

• Push-button operation with clear, easy-to-follow instructions and LCD display that simplifies control
• Centralized control panel that puts all circuitry and programmable controls in one Load Center
• Customizable configurations you can set up for a pool, spa, or pool/spa combination
• Choice of models that control either four or eight accessory functions
• Full programmability to optimize filtration, heating, and cleaning cycles
• Service mode lets you test and troubleshoot the system without going inside your home
• Time Out mode pauses programs and starts them back up automatically hours later
• Built-in diagnostics with self-testing and diagnostic screens to help solve problems
• Resettable circuit breakers you can access from outside your home

The EasyTouch started as a basic automation system and now has a 150-amp breaker base with room for 10 individual 1-inch breakers. This gives you complete control over your pool equipment.

Pentair EasyTouch pros and cons

Pros:

• Quick, one-button access to everything from the Load Center
• LCD display walks you through each operation step
• Several optional remote controllers to choose from (wireless, indoor panels, spa-side)
• Works with ScreenLogic2 Interface for mobile device control
• Blends with IntelliFlo pumps, IntelliBrite lighting, MagicStream laminars
• Controls up to two variable speed pumps
• Has 12 programmable scheduling options

Cons:

• Controls only 4 or 8 circuits compared to advanced systems
• Support will be limited as the product was discontinued in April 2023
• Won't control automatic pool covers
• Takes time to learn all programming features
• Chemical management limited to monitoring only
• Costs more if you have just one or two automated devices

Pentair EasyTouch pricing

You can choose from several EasyTouch system configurations at different price points:

• 4-Function Systems (pool only or spa only): $1,700-1,900
• 8-Function Systems (pool/spa combination): $2,000-3,700
• Systems with integrated IntelliChlor salt chlorination : $3,400-3,700
• Optional ScreenLogic2 device for smartphone control: Additional $600
• Optional wireless controllers : $200-500 depending on model

Prices change based on what components you choose. Systems with salt chlorine generators cost more. You should get professional installation, which adds $500-1,000 to the total cost.

Pentair EasyTouch best for

The Pentair EasyTouch works best for:

• Pool owners who want simple rather than complex features
• People moving up from manual controls who aren't tech experts
• Pool-only or spa-only setups that need basic automation
• Homes that need 4-8 pool/spa functions automated (pump, heater, lights, etc.)
• Current Pentair equipment owners looking for integrated control

This system shines when you want clear operation and simple programming without extra complications. The EasyTouch remains reliable even after being discontinued. It works well with essential Pentair accessories like the IntelliChlor sanitization system.

Many pool owners find that the EasyTouch hits the sweet spot between convenient automation and simple operation that other complex systems miss.

The Hayward OmniPL shines as the top pick for pool owners who want their swimming pool to work smoothly with their smart home setup. This automation system strikes a perfect balance between simple controllers and Hayward's premium OmniLogic system. You get great connectivity without dealing with unnecessary complexity.

Hayward OmniPL key features

The OmniPL builds on Hayward's resilient infrastructure while staying more affordable for mid-range pool automation needs. Here's what you get:

• External touchscreen display with a 15-foot cord that makes installation and programming simple
• Smart home integration that works perfectly with Amazon Alexa and Google Home voice control (on W models)
• Detailed pump control for up to 8 variable-speed pumps without relays
• Expandable relay system starting with 4 high-voltage relays that can grow to 8 total (6 internal plus 2 external Smart Relays)
• OmniDirect Mode supporting ColorLogic LED lighting with 20 extra color options, 7 exclusive shows, and precise dimming and speed control
• Built-in wireless and Ethernet connectivity for uninterrupted connection to home networks
• Salt chlorination integration with select models ready for salt cells or including TCell940 for pools up to 40,000 gallons

On top of that, it supports up to 4 valve actuators to control pool/spa switching, water features, and cleaning systems automatically.

Hayward OmniPL pros and cons

Pros:

• Accessible interface through the OmniLogic app lets you control your pool from anywhere
• Works with multiple Omni remote options (wireless, wall-mount, spa-side)
• You can upgrade parts without replacing everything
• 100A service subpanel fits 8 circuit breakers
• Every output can be programmed automatically
• Create up to 50 "Favorites" buttons for one-touch operation
• Set up 25 unique programmable themes for custom operation

Cons:

• Guests might find the mobile interface harder to use than simpler systems
• Getting into service mode takes too many steps
• Some users say switching between pool and spa modes isn't as simple as older systems
• You can't access the API directly, unlike some competitors

Hayward OmniPL pricing

Hayward positions the OmniPL as their mid-range automation option. You can choose from several models:

• HLPRO4W : Simple 4-relay system with app control (no salt cell)
• HLBPRO4SW : 4-relay system, salt-ready (needs a Hayward salt cell)
• HLBPLUS4W : 4-relay system that includes TCell940 for pools up to 40,000 gallons
• HLPRO4NW : 4-relay system without subpanel, with app control
• HLPROUPG : Update kit to upgrade existing ProLogic systems to OmniPL

Prices range from $1,500 to $2,500 depending on your chosen model and extra components. A professional should handle the installation, which might add to your total cost.

Hayward OmniPL best for

The Hayward OmniPL works great for:

• Smart home enthusiasts who want their pool controls to work with their existing setup
• Mid-range pool builds and renovations that need powerful automation without breaking the bank
• Pool owners moving up from older systems like ProLogic or AquaLogic
• Tech-savvy pool owners who want remote monitoring and control
• Pools with multiple features including variable speed pumps, lighting, and water features

The OmniPL really shines especially when you have energy efficiency in mind. Its precise control of variable speed pumps and scheduled equipment operation helps you save energy costs over time.

This system gives you a great mix of features and value if you want to control your backyard through voice commands and mobile apps without paying premium prices for Hayward's top-tier automation systems.

The Intermatic PE653RC helps pool owners automate their systems without spending too much money. This simple system gives you the most important automation features at half the price of premium controllers. Many budget-conscious homeowners find this an attractive choice.

Intermatic PE653RC key features

The MultiWave PE653RC keeps things simple and accessible while giving you core automation features:

• Five-circuit control lets you manage pumps, lights, cleaners, and heaters through a single interface
• Versatile pump compatibility works with single-speed, two-speed, and even Pentair IntelliFlo and IntelliPro variable-speed pumps
• Programmable scheduling with 24-hour timing that runs three ON/OFF events per circuit
• Wireless remote control with a backlit display you can use at night to check status
• Temperature management comes with a water temperature sensor and optional air temperature sensor that protects against freezing
• Z-Wave integration connects with your home automation platforms
• Durable enclosure rated Type 3R metal for indoor/outdoor weather protection

You can think of this system as a "plug and play" solution that works great when upgrading from mechanical timers or setting up automation in new pools.

Intermatic PE653RC pros and cons

Pros:

• Works with both 120V and 240V power systems
• Water temperature sensor comes standard while other systems charge extra
• Waterproof remote shows both water and air temperature
• Installation is easier than more complex systems
• Better performance than older relay technology in many cases
• Freeze protection runs pumps automatically when temperatures drop too low

Cons:

• Fewer independent circuits than premium controllers
• Freeze sensor might have issues in very cold weather
• Not as customizable as pricier options
• Works with just one body of water (pool OR spa, not both)
• No dedicated smartphone app (needs Z-Wave for smart home features)

Intermatic PE653RC pricing

The PE653RC stands out as a budget-friendly choice in pool automation. Current prices show:

• Retail price range : $699-$950 based on retailer and accessories
• Sale prices can drop to $699, which saves you money
• Standard package gives you a receiver, wireless remote, water temperature sensor, air temperature sensor, batteries, equipment labels, and mounting hardware

You can buy extra accessories like freeze protection probes (178PA28A) or actuator controls (P4243ME) separately if needed.

Premium automation systems cost $1,500-2,500 to start. The PE653RC gives great value to pool owners who want simple automation without too many bells and whistles.

Intermatic PE653RC best for

The PE653RC works best for:

• Pool owners watching their budget who want simple automation features
• Single pool systems that don't need complex valve controls or water features
• Hands-on homeowners who can handle basic electrical work
• Older pools switching from mechanical timers to digital controls
• Small to medium pools with standard equipment

This system makes a great starter automation package if you're not ready to spend more money. Z-Wave compatibility lets you connect it to your smart home setup. You get remote control without buying into expensive proprietary apps and systems.

The PE653RC saves time by automating your equipment schedules, monitoring temperatures, and giving you remote control. These benefits make pool ownership easier, whatever your budget might be.

The Zodiac iAquaLink leads the pool automation industry with its top-rated mobile app that puts complete pool management at your fingertips. This smartphone control system has earned over 50,000 five-star reviews, letting you manage your pool from any location.

Zodiac iAquaLink key features

The iAquaLink system delivers detailed pool control by combining hardware, web services, and mobile applications:

• Industry-leading mobile app with easy-to-use interface for iOS and Android devices
• Anytime, anywhere control of up to 32 pool and spa features through any web-connected device
• Multi-platform compatibility supporting more device types than any other pool automation system
• WiFi connectivity options including hotspot mode, WPS pushbutton setup, and support for both 802.11b and 802.11g networks
• No subscription costs - completely free app and service with no ongoing fees
• Multiple user accounts letting family members and service professionals access separately without sharing passwords
• Global control of pool equipment from pumps and heaters to water features and landscape lighting

The system operates by connecting an iAquaLink web connect device to an AquaLink control center at your equipment pad. This creates a bridge between your pool equipment and internet router.

Zodiac iAquaLink pros and cons

Pros:

• Users report setup completion in under 30 minutes
• Native apps or HTML5 web app work with almost any smartphone or tablet
• Single app login controls multiple pools
• Smooth integration with all Jandy/Zodiac equipment
• Commands execute in about 1 second with immediate responsiveness
• Multiple language support includes English, French, Spanish, German, and others
• WiFi connects faster compared to previous models

Cons:

• Certain iOS versions may have compatibility issues
• Physical control panels offer more scheduling features
• Interface needs time to learn without help menus
• Detailed energy usage reporting features are not available yet
• iOS app's programming capabilities disappoint some users

Zodiac iAquaLink pricing

Several configurations of the iAquaLink system are available:

• iAquaLink 2.0 (IQ900-A) - complete kit including web connect device costs approximately $560
• iQ20-A - web connect interface system for existing AquaLink setups
• iQ30 - newer model with improved signal strength and connectivity
• IQ904-P - pool-only automation bundle

Existing Zodiac/Jandy AquaLink users can choose conversion kits that cost less than new systems. Many tech-savvy owners complete self-installation successfully, though professional installation is recommended.

Zodiac iAquaLink best for

The Zodiac iAquaLink serves perfectly for:

• Smartphone-centric pool owners who value mobile control capabilities
• Frequent travelers who need pool setting adjustments while away
• Existing Jandy/Zodiac equipment owners wanting remote capabilities
• Multi-property managers who need one interface to control multiple pools
• Pool service professionals requiring client pool monitoring remotely

The system excels at practical uses like heating your spa before coming home, starting cleaner cycles remotely, or controlling pool/spa lighting from anywhere. The iAquaLink's highly-rated app and straightforward interface make it the top choice for users seeking the most accessible mobile experience in pool automation.

Pool owners know the constant struggle of maintaining perfect water chemistry with fluctuating pH and chlorine levels. The Hayward Sense and Dispense system solves this challenge. This automated water chemistry management system brings commercial-grade technology to home pools, making it available to residential users.

Hayward Sense and Dispense key features

The Hayward Sense and Dispense works as a chemistry automation system that:

• Continuously monitors sanitization and pH levels with up-to-the-minute data analysis
• Dynamically dispenses chemicals based on your pool's needs
• Controls pH levels using either Carbon Dioxide (CO2) or Muriatic Acid
• Uses a proportional feed algorithm to sample water consistently and avoid dramatic chemical swings common with manual methods
• Features professional-grade ORP probes that measure actual sanitizer activity instead of just chemical residual levels
• Supports compatibility with Hayward OmniLogic, OmniHub, Aqua Rite Pro, and Pro Logic control systems

The system works as an add-on module and needs integration with an existing Hayward automation system.

Hayward Sense and Dispense pros and cons

Pros:

• Maintains the most consistent water quality possible
• Saves on installation costs through complete integration
• Gives you a single source to check status and control
• Measures ORP for accurate water quality assessment instead of basic chemical readings
• Protects equipment by shutting down if it runs too long

Cons:

• You need to buy pH dispensing devices separately (peristaltic pump or solenoid valve)
• Works only with specific Hayward automation systems
• Probes need constant water contact to work properly
• Dealers report that CO2 systems are being discontinued

Hayward Sense and Dispense pricing

The system costs about $1,084. This price includes professional-grade ORP and pH probes, probe cell, and necessary hardware. Remember that you'll need extra budget for pH dispensing equipment like the AQL-CHEM2 CO2 kit.

Hayward Sense and Dispense best for

We recommend the Hayward Sense and Dispense for:

• Pool owners who already use Hayward systems (OmniLogic, OmniHub, Aqua Rite Pro, Pro Logic)
• Pools that need precise, automated chemical control
• Homeowners who want to stop constant manual water testing
• Salt-chlorinated pools that need regular pH adjustments

The Hayward Sense and Dispense brings professional technology to your home pool. It keeps sanitization and pH levels balanced automatically, so you can spend less time testing and more time swimming.

Pool automation systems are a smart investment for pool owners who want to get their free time back. These systems turn tedious pool maintenance into a simple task you can manage easily. Each system has its strengths - Hayward OmniPL works great with smart homes, Pentair IntelliCenter saves energy, and Intermatic PE653RC fits tighter budgets.

Your specific needs will determine the best automation system for you. In spite of that, quality systems save you lots of time by handling routine tasks on their own. On top of that, these systems often pay for themselves through lower chemical use and better energy management.

Pool owners who use automation spend much less time on maintenance and get better water quality. The ability to control your pool's functions from anywhere improves the whole experience. You can get your pool ready for a swim no matter where you are.

The upfront costs of $700 to $3,500 might look steep, but the long-term benefits are worth the investment. Automated monitoring gives you peace of mind, and precise equipment control makes pool ownership the relaxed experience it should be.

Take time to consider your budget limits, system compatibility, feature priorities, and future plans before picking a system that fits your pool lifestyle. The ideal automation system works naturally in the background while you enjoy clear water without any hassle.

Hayward - Better Pool Automation

Pentair - Pool Automation Benefits

Poolside Tech - User Guide